So under your way of thinking......we don't actually pay taxes either. Because according to you, we never received the money, so I guess we never paid in the taxes either, because we never wrote them a check. With the 15% "giveback" and the taxes that are taken out of my check, it sure makes it a lot smaller. But, I guess I'm really out nothing, since I didn't actually write them a check for the money. Yep, makes sense to me.
I'm shocked that you have even engaged in such a ridiculous argument...I though you were way above this...I stand corrected.
Withholding is, yes, in a way. Fictictous. Same as the Federal Deficit. They dare to call keeping the taxrates exactly the same as they have been the past ten years a 'Cost of $800 Billion'. It cost nothing. Taxes didn't go from what they are now at 1159pm on Dec 31st to raising at 1200 midnight to $800 Billion less at 1201am Jan 1st. It's all accounting. Baseline Budgeting. For you to REALLY see that income, we need to End Taxing Income totally. End Base Line Budgeting (Where some Washington Beauracrat assumes more taxes will come in and all beauraus will spend more). Go with the Fair Tax-- everyone then keeps his ENTIRE paycheck (The only way you can actually Receive that money); everyone is taxed the same in a National Sales Tax. No income tax, no corporate tax, no cap gains tax. No filing, no escaping, no receipts kept, no writeoffs. THERE- you DO get the full amount. Only then. In the meantime, it's only imaginary, only in accounting. And Totally worthless paper from the government. All in all, they can call it that you made $60,000 last year, or they can call it that you made a Trillion. Matters not if you never received it.
I'm simply going by the Dictionary. Can't 'give back' what you never had. Not splitting hairs, not making it up. To say it's a give back is a lie, and nothing more than jealous political posturing. You either agree to work for the wage, or you reject it and quit. Very, Very, Very simple. I made one statement at the beginning, ("Show me the check?") I'm not the one upset-- apparently many of you are. Why, since it's simple language from a guy with a keyboard, is beyond me. Must be true then.....I study History. Misrepresenting Language is the way the Left urges 'The Masses' to rebel in 'The Opressed against the Opressors.' Don't fall into that trap. The Company is Broke. The Union agreed to help them by working for less. Simple, actually. No money changed hands. Don't get your panties in a knot over it. Accept it or quit.
I'm not a jealous person. I'm not horrible, or mean. I just don't understand jealousy, and boiled to its nibs-- that's all this 'argument' is. Wanting to blame someone. It's not logical, it's not practical. It comes from Satan. Get over it, and quit looking to blame others. It simply 'IS'. And it's NOT a 'Giveback.'