I read, with interest, the linked article and I can see the point your trying to make regarding Hostess and it's relevancy to the YRCF situation....However the first sentence, "The jobs of most of the workers who used to make Twinkies and other Hostess cakes, and their union, are not coming back".
That says a lot right there...
The article further states that management misused the gains from the concessions....but how do we really know with any certainty about the inner workings of Hostess....or for that matter, YRCF? Considering how Management is anti-Union in general, it is not outside the realm of that possibility....
IF that is the case with YRCF it is outside of our ability to do anything about that anyway.....Risking the loss of jobs, especially during this time of economic and employment weakness, will not right that wrong......and those at the top of the Corporate hierarchy are not going to suffer at all...not even a tiny bit.....It's always the workers that take the brunt of it......I know that some say how debt free and wise they have been and how this will not affect them.....or they have a working spouse that will lessen the impact......Yes that's all well and good but they are not thinking of how it might impact others that have a greater reliance on this Companys survival.....for example, they may have dependents that need healthcare. What is another aspect in the role of a Union Brotherhood?.... isn't that looking out for every ones best interests, along with the the best interest of the Union? Notice that first line I quoted from the article that you linked to....... It said the "workers and their Union " are not coming back....... The Twinkies are back...but not the Union or their workers.....If YRCF were to close....it would be the same....yes the freight would still need to be moved...but it won't be by the Union and their drivers.....
If the Union employees pass these concessions....and the Company still goes bankrupt at a later date....it would be hard for management to say it's the Unions fault, like they will, if it's voted down and they close......To those that say shutting it down somehow equates to having dignity or going out with your head held high...is a bunch of dramatic Bravado...nothing more......to go out after doing everything reasonably possible....and without the Union to be the scapegoat is a preferred way... that would do more to reflect the blame to who is really responsible.....
You could say that....but actually those things you cited, with the exception of morale, would actually save the Company money.....that is what the concessions are about...savings....Freight discounting has been going on for years....all the Carriers engage in that practice... Give a deep discount to try and get the business and then try and raise the rate later to make some money...... Personally, my thought would be if none of the Carriers did that..rates would be more stable....but that is just my opinion....
Low morale is a problem for any Company...but it is especially troubling at a time like this.....I know it's a problem and it's a problem that is not solved easily overnight...
However, each of us as individuals, can do something about it....Besides morale....we have a Motivation problem.....the two are closely related concepts..
While motivation is an individual concept, morale is a group concept. Thus, through motivation ,the individual, with our inherent differences, can have an impact among the rest of the employees as a group, thus the morale of the employees can be increased. So by taking that into consideration it is easier to see how each of us can influence the larger group. If each of us takes a more positive attitude.....that over time can have an impact on the Group....think about it...would you rather spend your work time with complaining, whining co-workers or be around people with a pleasant or happy demeanor?.....Morale, good or bad, largely depends on each of us and how we respond to our situation as well as those around us....If you don't like the morale.... you can do something about it.....set the example yourself......
It is as I have stated in previous posts.. Look around at what other similar jobs are paying in wages and benefits....time off.....vacation ect. Compare that to what your current job pays and factor in your seniority...is it such that you can bid for runs or time slots that you like.... If the "average" driving job start to look better......then I would say it's time to move on......but as long as that's not true...it makes more sense to stay the course......
It is impossible to say what two years hence will look like......as far a vote, if that were to be the case....I'd have to say that it would entirely depend on the situation and the circumstances at that time.....
I hope that answered the question to your satisfaction...
Now I ask you, How low of a wage and how much are you willing to pay for Benefits along with having to start at the bottom someplace else and the lack of seniority and the "perks" that go with it?
We can't allow the issues of management bonuses and what they do, or don't do, dictate how we vote..... We can not stop what they are doing or may do in the future.....other than shutting down the Company....but as I said before...who is going to suffer the most.....or shall I say who will be the only ones that will suffer? It will be the workers....not them.....why would anyone want to risk their Jobs....the jobs of their fellow Teamster brothers and sisters....and those that will come behind....just because we don't approve of management and their bonuses , or whatever the "beef" is...Everyone likes to complain about the Union...well think about how less strong the Union is without the Hostess members....think about how less strong it will be for our ABF or UPS brothers and sisters if we allow this Company to fail? ... It's as I said before....the whole issue goes beyond just us as individuals.....The ramifications are far reaching, irreversible and final......Don't allow short sighted overemotional thinking cloud your best judgment.....
Thank you Mr hanalad for engaging in an adult level discussion without the mention of "panties" underwear drawers" and "Balls" !