I believe brother canary made my case for me below. The union has to defend the slackers as well as the hard workers, so tell me how that doesn’t breed a culture of slackers? I may be painting with a broad brush, but human nature is pretty predictable.
“They can work me long, but they can’t work me hard...”
I don't think I quite....made your case..for you. Theft of time in a Union job,...no matter the length, duration, or circumstance,...is a fireable offense. It will uphold in arbitration cases, too. Stealing is theft,....whether it be time or merchandise,...or paperclips from the dispatch pencil holder....
In the case I made above, the COMPANY protected the man. The Union was quite prepared to accept discipline for the guy,....because the same guy was involved in a very important grievance with wide-ranging effects on the region,.......that the company wanted the Union to "bargain away",.......in order to save this guy's job....
In a Union job,..."innocent until proven guilty"....requires a thorough impartial investigation,...not mere allegation. But if someone is proven guilty, all the Union can do is try to migitate the punishment.....Operative word is "try".....
Without going into details,.....some people get hired, and are almost immediately identified as.....trouble,.....by the company. Union or not,...companies have 90 days to get rid of the guy,...without prejudice,.......as long as they aren't firing him for Union activities....
The company retains some of these guys,....KNOWING...they will become a permanent irritant and black eye for the Union...
That being said,.....did the company you are employed by ever hire an absolute imbecile? Are there any ..."slackers"...at your place?
Or,.....are all the non-Union barns paragons of highly productive, company-oriented, hard-working, constantly moving employees,........with NO lazy or "slacking" shirkers,.........NO "fair-haired company pets" who do very little for the same pay,.....
Because the non-Union companies use that "Employment-at-Will" law to constantly sweep the....deadwood...out of the barns?
Would that be true of your company? Would that be true of any company?
The only difference between Union barns and non-Union barns,..is that you will get an advocate, and an impartial trial, and a consideration of extenuating circumstances,....in the face of charges....
As opposed to an indifferent dismissal out-of-hand, based on company allegations......
I don't see where that creates a "culture of slackers"............I can see company officials putting that out as propaganda so that guys can claim "one more reason not to join a Union.."
I know you're not a company official, Brother.......I'm just saying that non-union companies like to create "reasons"...or memes, if you will,......so that guys think they have a "reason" not to view Unions favorably......
And, yes,.....it is painting with a broad brush............But when did that ever stop a company using propaganda?