I guess its easy to say you are not giving back when its not your pay check that has a statement on it telling us how much at 15% is being taking from your check weekly and up to date yearly
I'd say we have a problem in communication! Legalese vs reality.
The difference is recorded on the paystub because it is still the contract, amended. In Reality, the old contract ended when you agreed to work for less. In legalese they can't do that, because of the MOU. Let's say (to simplify) that a worker is now being paid 850 for 40 hours. In reality- that's the pay. That's what should be on the stub. Under legalese tho, it shows 1,000 minus 150=850. We both know that YRCW Claims that they wouldn't be in business IF they actually had to pay the 1,000. I skip the legalese and watch reality. Others do not. That 1,000 minus 15% becomes a burr under their saddle, stirring resentment, disturbing morale. I concentrate on what is reality- the 850.
This first was promulgated by Marx in 1848 thru 'Manifesto on Communism'. His opening paragraphs is that all wealth comes from the workers, stolen by the wealthy thru wages. He proposes siezing of all private property, and the State making all decisions. Communism always fails, even though our Public Education System has been proposing it since the Wilson Adminstration.
Collectivism is Great when it's private co-ops/ trade unions negotiating to raise pay and benefits for the average worker who is free to come and go at any time. However, when it becomes a religious type fervor, it becomes evil and consumes the mind thru jealousy. Ignore that there is a false '1,000' on your check; concentrate on the reality of the 850, and work to fix the things that are actually In Your Control.....
(I repeat- I'd vote no on the current proposal, too. Just for the record. But it wouldn't consume me.....)