I really don't see how it's that big of a screwing, they will make top rate when they get there. If this raise were to be given as a percentage that's how it would be. Our apprentices are payed a percentage of top scale, every year of service you get a bigger percentage until you "top" out. This year we got $.90 for top rate, so the apprentices didn't get $.90 they got some percentage of that depending on their years of service. Lots of companies base their pay on a percentage nothing wrong with it. Ask a Sysco Cleveland driver hired in the last 10 years about their pay, anyone hired after a certain date (I don't remember the date but it was a past contract ratification date) gets $4 dollars an hour less permanently. And that's a union shop. At least your new hires will top out in three years at the same rate as you.