Doesn't sound right, what did they sign on the grievance? no merit? we always fought a chargeable/preventable, didn't always win, but didn't give it up easy. did this happen at night? was there working lights? any signs? caution /warning? any bumpers to stop rollways?I never received a letter for this accident, and the local said it’s not contractual. I did write a protest letter but that went nowhere. So I was charged with an accident (that didn’t involve driving) lost all safe driving miles and the local says I wasn’t disciplined and it’s not contractual. Never heard such a thing in 23 years.