I hear what ya'll are saying about policy being just what it is - policy. But if we closely examine the policies that we find fault with and give legitimate points of why they are flawed, we should expect and demand the attention of policymakers in regards to why policy should be changed.
First in, First out. Probably one of the most hated policies just for the simple fact that there are so many bogus circumstances that can disrupt it's intended purpose.
I'll offer a situation that I know will ring true with a lot of other guys out there. Myself and the driver just below me in seniority are given our hooks at the same time. My dolly has a bad pigtail and I have to go find another one. Those few minutes give the junior driver the opportunity to dispatch first and slip out ahead of me to our destination. Magically, somehow or another that junior driver manages to make the 4 and a quarter hour drive without a bathroom break, but any other night, that truckstop halfway there would have been visited. Fair? No. In this instance, an exception for the senior driver should be made. As long as the senior driver made his run time, he should be the first out.
Another example is two drivers dispatch at the same time. The senior driver stops for a bathroom break. The junior driver doesn't. The junior driver gets cut loose from the FAC first. Fair? No. In this instance (similiar to the previous example) the senior driver should be the first out, as long as he made his run time. It would be nice if we could rely on junior drivers to tell the FAC FOS to go ahead and let the senior man out first, but this just isn't a realistic expectation.
We all know that the first in, first out policy was intended to encourage us to make it to the FAC in a timely manner. But what policymakers choose to ignore is that it has made the trip to the FAC an unsafe race half the time. Why not go by seniority and whether or not the driver made his run time when considering who gets to leave first. That is the FAIR way to do it.
If we provide actual, real-world flaws to our policies AND suggest fair, unbiased solutions, how can our leaders ignore these facts and sleep at night? If we are ignored after presenting such information then shame on them. Policymakers and policyfollowers need to work together on issues such as this one. It is ESSENTIAL!