It's funny you should say that because I just had a discussion last week with my business agent. Some of our guys were getting 55+ hours per week, yet others were getting less than 40. We still use some drivers on the outbound dock and those 55+ guys were out there every night. I asked my TM to arrange for the guys with the least amount of hours to get that dock time and he agreed. My business agent disagreed and said that by strict seniority rules, those 55+ guys get the dock time and those junior guys go home. I said not as long as I am your shop steward.
I don't agree with everything the Teamsters do. Now, when a contract is signed, that situation may pose some problems for me. Senior guys can grieve that situation and win. That would cause my TM to go right back to giving the senior guys the dock time and sending the junior guys home.
I DO think a 24 year, 2 million mile guy deserves some consideration when rules are applied. Unless it's a catastrophic event, rules can be modified to accommodate someone with an outstanding history of service to the company. We get a credit for each year of accident free driving, up to 2, I believe. Why can't something similar be done for drive cam events. Also, under what circumstances did the event occur. Was he driving 70 mph in the rain, or was he sitting in bumper to bumper traffic. It makes a difference.
It's in these types of situations where a grievance and arbitration process can save a GOOD drivers job.