nospinzone said:
Your arguement of no track record is the only one that holds water. I've made my decision based on the comparison of the APWA's plan for success and IBT's plan and recent past performance. APWA's pension goals are possible because ALL of your pension contributions will go to you, as opposed to the Teamster plans where 60cents of your dollar goes to a non-UPS retiree. APWA can double the retirement checks for a new hire under their plan because the member will be getting ALL of their money instead of half. Negotiating leverage comes from the unity of the employees. IBT's only leverage is the willingness of the UPS employees to collectively threaten with a strike. The leverage wasn't there when IBT went for Overnite the last time, resulting in IBT's embarrasing defeat. If the people of UPSF choose to collectively pursue representation from APWA, the unity and leverage will be there. Harrisburg is going APWA because collectively and in unity
THEY WANT APWA. The people have done the leg work. Eason and Skillman hardly had to lift a finger outside of answering the barrage of phone calls from Pa.
Who's to say the same thing won't happen with IBT. Hell, that's already happened with IBT.
Hoffa Campaign Busted for Laundering Members' Dues AGAIN Teamster $100,000 Club Check out that club link. The salaries that these guys are getting are outrageous. APWA has set up
transparency and membership oversight to prevent such wasteful managment.
I agree. But there would be just as much leverage if not more with Blue and Brown represented by APWA. Leverage is only the capability of executing a financially threatening strike, which is the only thing UPS cares about. IBT's vast and distracting interests/liabilities that rely on UPS dues and pension contributions will prevent them from aggresively negotiating with UPS. Teamster's need UPS more than UPS needs them.
Your statement here makes total sense. Pensions are having trouble. And as a UPSF employee, with a currently well funded retirement plan, you want to give that money over to the Teamsters so they can throw it into their money pit? APWA is a vehicle that would allow, if the people on the Blue side desire, to stay in the current retirement plan or join the APWA pension fund. The flexibility is there which allows the member to choose which direction to go.
But thats just my opinion.
The reason for the defeat of the teamster's in the past, was a concauction of a numerous thing's.
1. The co. had just recently come out of bankruptcy.(Within 10 Years) Thanx to UP.
2. Leo also said, and meant, and did , (as far as I am concearned) Overtime ( sorry guy's) Will promote better job's, equipment monies, bennies, and so on and so on. Every year things were better.
3. Hoffa made this public statement,"If we did not join the union, He will shut us down". Why would I want to vote for a person with such a goal.
4. The overall atmosphere in most terminal's I've visited was pleasant in comparison to a teamster terminal.
5. Most driver's as long as they were doing thier job was not bothered.
And I could go on and on.
The differance, as I had said before, is we have the clutch of the entire co. being teamster's .
If we now nothing of the retirement yet, which must still be negotiated by the teamster's and officials of UPS, how can we say at this time that we will not end up with a SEPF that can be just as profitable? If not we can refuse the contract...
As far as the pention fund I will say that if my best friend was to jump off a bridge , I won't, No experience could lead to disaster. I could go back in time and get all kind's of specific's on people who launder monies, our polititian's do it every day, at our cost.
So as far as I am concearned there is no sustinanace to be craved in that statement.
I have no problem with the APWA per say, I now very little of them Aside from what I argue, which I think most bare in agreement with, But if a salesmen want's to sell a car, he or she will get in your face!!! I see that happening here.
If harrisburgh goes APWA, and the rest teamster's, then I would say "may the best man win" And maybe in time the co. may infact switch over if a track record is proven..
Another thing I think is quite funny, is alot of rumor's state we will get better bennies and working condition's than what the teamster's can offer, Is god at the neg. table for them, we are freight, not small package, I am expecting better than what we currently have, but on the same note how can the APWA do better?
Just on pention is not enough, there are farmore thing's to consider.